User talk:FandomEntertainment

I've removed a few links you recently provided to articles associated with The L Word. Please refer to wikipedia's guidelines regarding self-promotion and advertising. Looking at the history of this wikipedia account, it seems to only exist to promote fansites so possibly you were unaware that this is generally not appropriate for wikipedia. -Markeer 15:16, 22 October 2006 (UTC)

FANDOM ENTERTAINMENT REPLIES: I was unaware that being new to Wikipedia made one ineligible to post links. I have yet to come across that rule.

On virtually every page relating to the L word is an entry for: AfterEllen's L Word section Comprehensive news, reviews, interviews, recaps, and polls related to the series.

This entry *never* gets deleted, yet it is an "advertisement for a commercial web site." Either all links to commercial sites get deleted, or mine stays. I'd be happy to argue this to whatever authority at wikipedia you choose to take this up with.

The *reality* is both sites house two of the biggest fan collections for anything related to the L word.

Why are there links in wikipedia if not to provide users places for more information.

Both sites should stay.


 * That's a fair argument, although my response would be that both sites should go, not stay. I've started a section on the L Word talk page to seek consensus on criteria for fansite links.  Please feel free to add your voice there. If you have another comment to make to me personally, feel free to add it either here or on my talk page (I've added your talk page to my watchlist for the next couple weeks so I'll see it either place). -Markeer 16:39, 23 October 2006 (UTC)