User talk:Finely Ben-Hadd

September 24,2007

Dear Mr. Hobbs,

It has been quite some time since we have talked, and I have a lot to say. I have a lot of questions that you may be able to answer and help with. First of all, you may feel that I don't trust you or that I dislike you, so I would like to clear that up in a few words. Many people have followed this case in Preble County and Indiana as well. Many have said to me "Why was this?" or "Why was that not brought to trial?" or "Why did this person not testify?". For instance, many have asked about Bruce Kessler, Gail Miller, Marilyn Robinson, Officer Kent Moore, Carolyn Young and many others as well. Everything about this case has been put out there, either by snail mail in the begining, or more recently, via our web-site. A very large percentage of people and voters have viewed it all and have read the Criminal Appearance Docket. That brought out the "Monday-morning Quarterbacks" on both sides, but I have always said to many people that Mr. Hobbs was the lawyer. Yes, I had some disagreement with some of the non-attendance for Defendant Billy Scott, as stated above. I have been asked by hundreds of Preble County citizens if the investigation over the past 17 years turned up any dirt or corruption on Mr. Hobbs. I stated I had found nothing, and many people were glad to hear that.

They also see the truth on the web-site. They know about the threats on your life and your office. We laid it all out and they know we have lied about nothing. Many people in Preble County find me very credible; even the other side now.

I think it is time to take advantage of the latest evidence that our web-site and new witnesses have produced, but I have some very important questions and information I would like to go over with you and only you first.

I knew there were people that knew Tony Young was not at the lake party, but I had to prove it. Now we can. I knew the Johnson's were at the lake party and not at the beach party. They were right there where Lesa Buckley's body was found. I can now prove this. I have written statements and audio statements, but how do we protect these people if a new trial was granted? Who would be the Prosecutor and Judge? What county would the new trial be held in? And would the news media feel sorry for the Buckley's, who are the "victims"? Personally, I don't even believe a new trial would be granted, even if God himself were my lawyer.I believe Billy Scott to be a political prisoner. A new Prosecutor and Judge, in their right political minds would surely turn it down. I beleive all I now have would be res judicata. Now my question is; could a motion be filed for a special Prosecutor out of Columbus, Ohio, in order to review and possibly reopen the case and investigation? I intend to use the evidence that we have gathered which proves the Johnson's were there and that Tony Young was not there. I would also remind the State Prosecutor that there was no corpus delicti and Billy Scott never confessed. He made a sarcastic remark at a party after being harassed for over a year.

I would like to say that if Mr. Votel would do his duty and reopen the case, a large group of voters in Preble County would more than welcome his input. It would also begin to show that he can clean the county up. However, I have been told by my "courthouse mouse" Votel and David Lindloff (the Nazi) are attached at the hips. It is also my understanding that Mr. "Motel" has no morals, so he probably doesn't have an ethical background.

That being said, other pieces of evidence that could tie into the investigation would be Debbie Ridge aka "Rocking Chair". She has information on the Johnson's and I believe her brother does also. Also, where are the green blankets referenced on pages 805-893? They had hair and seman on them that did not match Billy Scott's hair. So, whose seman was it? How could Larry Swihart say the blankets have nothing to do with the case, while Frank Ford and the Miami Valley Crime Lab suggest they do? Our new witnesses saw Lisa Johnson at the barn and have been threatened with their and their family's life if they ever comes forward with this information. We have their statements.

Now, Mr. Hobbs, I am sure you know that Billy Scott is labeled a sexual predadtor due to the hearing on September 29, 2006. At that hearing, Jim and Mary Buckley were there giving the thumbs up after the Judge put the label on Billy Scott. Here is something you will find very interesting: The day before, Cindy Adams (Lesa Buckley's Sister) requested a visit to see Billy Scott. We have the letter she wrote to Billy. This girl knows Billy Scott is innocent and so does Lesa Buckley's brother, Jason Buckley. I do not believe Jim and Mary Buckley Knew of Cindy Adams' visit, but they may now. I have been told many times over the years that Jason and Cindy knew Billy Scott is innocent, but Jim and Mary said to leave it alone.

Mr. Hobbs, I feel sorry for Mary Buckley. She lost her daughter and was grossly misled by Rebecca Ferguson and crew. I believe she was used as a puppet for political gain. As far as Jim Buckley: He has a lot of nerve to do a thumbs up at the hearing. I have statements from his neighbors that he had been sexually abusing Lesa Buckley which led to Mary Buckley getting Lesa an apartment in town. He, Jim, is a sexual predator.

Now, in closing this letter, many people wanted me to contact you and I promised I would. But, I will say this: The people in Preble County want closure in regards to this case and the untouchable Johnson's crime spree. There will be another election upcoming, and I will launch a campaign with other supporters to change the mentality of unjust Prosecutors, like former Durham County District Attorney Mike Nifong. Finally, one last question: If the State reopens it on their nickel and if you reopen; is it pro bono publico or what? Our supporters want to know.

Sincerely,

Mr. Guy B. Scott

P.S., Mr. Hobbs, why have you not contacted Mr. Scott. You have the number. You have had 9 months to reply to this letter that was forwarded to me. I have been studying this case for 2 years now. I am appalled at your inaction. You should be bared from your profession and held acountable for your actions concerning the trial of Billy Scott.

Third-Year Law Student

Finely Ben-Hadd (talk) 17:40, 14 May 2008 (UTC)