User talk:Gbshaffner

Then I Fly album removal
I read your reason for the removal of the Then I Fly album. The link is not a blog. If you search for the album it comes up for multiple links that reference the release date and they are not blogs. I will be submitting the album to the list again. It is real and the reference link is not a blog. The information and reference are both within the guidelines. I hope the removal is not due to your opinion, the release and existence of the album is factual information. Thank you Gbshaffner (talk) 23:27, 5 July 2016 (UTC)


 * You misunderstood my comment. I undid your good faith addition on July 3, and stated the reason as "Undid good faith addition of Then I Fly as non-notable. Suggest creating band wiki-page first, then re-listing." When I undid the good faith addition on July 4, I short handed my reason when I stated "Undid addition of Then I Fly, same reason as before." Until you or someone else creates a Wikipedia article for the band, or until you can provide a couple of notable news sources (Pitchfork, NME, Billboard, Rolling Stone, etc.) articles listing the album, then the band will be considered non-notable. Once the band has been established as notable, then lesser notability news sources such as iTunes, or regional newspapers can be used.  First prove the group is notable.  List of 2016 albums should not be the first place in Wikipedia that the group or album is listed.  This is an ancillary article, not a primary article.  I strongly suggest you create an article for the band first.  Then, go ahead and list the album on the album release list. Mburrell (talk) 23:38, 5 July 2016 (UTC)