User talk:Geo Swan/I suggest some topic specific notability criteria for extrajudicial captives

I'm not sure about the second criterion. We don't consider the normal-judicial trial of a person to constitute a second event to their alleged crime's first event. The military-commission trial, furthermore, isn't technically extrajudicial, it's nonstandard-judicial (depending on POV, possibly improper-judicial). But it's still judicial. So I'd say that it might qualify them for a list entry, but not for a solo article.

The rest I have no problem with, although copyediting is in order. They seem to be logical extrapolations of BLP1E for this kind of person. - Jorgath (talk) (contribs) 21:53, 20 August 2012 (UTC)