User talk:Giant peach

Hi. I'm sorry to be reverting your changes to James Katz, but it appears to be the right thing to do.

Many new contributors to Wikipedia write articles about bands or musicians. Everybody seems to want their favorite musician to be listed in Wikipeida, but ultimately, this poses a problem. Does every musician warrant an article on Wikipedia?

The goal of Wikipedia is to build a free encyclopedia. If every musician had his own article, these might well overwhelm articles on other topics. A line has to be drawn in the sand somewhere. With this in mind, Wikipedia editors have developed guidelines for the inclusion of musical acts into Wikipedia. These can be found at WP:BAND. James Katz does not seem to meet any of the criteria listed here. But please, read over this page. If he does meet one of the many criteria listed there, then let me know, and I will stop contesting your changes to James Katz. If he does not, then the article must be removed. His article can always be created when he becomes more notable. lowercase 07:51, 1 June 2006 (UTC)