User talk:GimliDotNet/Archives/2014/November

Radagast Changes
Hello!

You recently changed the Radagast entry. You said that the image belonged in the adaptations section of the articles, but I would argue that the infrobox should be used when implementing the image. On similar articles such as Dumbledore and Katniss Everdeen, an image is displayed in the info box which depicts an actor playing the part in an ADAPATATION of the work. I believe that the change was both warranted and helpful to the article. I am planning on readding the image to the infobox, but changing the wording to solve the continuity issue. I hope we can both agree that Radagast has earned a place that would benefit from an image of the character in Tolkien's Arda. Thanks, and sorry for any confusion!

--Emnp3 (talk) 17:09, 11 November 2014 (UTC) > Tom C

Continuity
Hi, it seems that the consensus may have changed. An article deemed "good" by the administrators of the Middle Earth Portal (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Figwit) contains an image like the one we are discussing. I think that the consensus may not be an actual consensus. Would you mind leaving it as it was, until we get to the bottom of this from the admins? As many other groups that cover these types of topics (Book and Movie characters) follow this form, and it is an arguably more visually appealing and informative entry when the image is displayed in the info box. Another example would be (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treebeard) where Treebeard is depicted in an ADAPTIVE work by the Artist Inger Edelfeldt.

--Emnp3 (talk) 20:25, 11 November 2014 (UTC) < Tom C


 * In a related move I have nominated two non-free Middle-earth images for deletion at Files for deletion/2014 November 11. You might want to chime in there. De728631 (talk) 22:04, 11 November 2014 (UTC)