User talk:Gmenezchahade/Life and Times of Frederick Douglass/QuintonHogshead Peer Review

I think you've done a really great job! I'm shocked that a book by Fredrick Douglass doesn't have a good plot summary, and I thank you for adding one that was so desperately needed. I don't have any notes about your summary of the text, I think that it is really well executed, and you've managed to shrink the entire autobiography down into a few paragraphs. there is nothing wordy, extraneous or bias. There are a few spelling and grammar errors, so you might want to give this another read to catch all of those.

For your section on reactions to the text, I think that it might be useful to talk a little more about contemporary sources. How reactions to Douglass have changed over time since the 1800s. You could stand to be more specific there.

QuintonHogshead (talk) 19:45, 29 November 2022 (UTC)