User talk:Grahap

Hi. I undid your recent edit to Girl group

This is what you added: "Little Mix, who is the first and, so far, only group to win the The X Factor, is the first girl group since The Pussycat Dolls to reach the US top 5 with their debut album, as well as earning the highest debut US chart position by a British girl group, breaking the record previously held by the Spice Girls"

First, I don't think they are the only group to win the X Factor...didn't Alex and Sierra win X factor too? There may be others as well that I don't remember.

Second, the other 2 records you added are very narrow and meaningless, especially in the scope of the history of girl groups. Are those really big enough achievements to be more than just footnotes in the entire history of girl group? Look at the other achievements noted in the article..they are for achievements that are the "first/best/biggest OF ALL TIME" in the world or at least in a major music market. On the other hand, the achievements you listed require limitations to "debut album only" + "British only" + "first week chart # only" + "billboard top 5 only"(instead of just #1, which multiple girl groups have achieved but aren't even noted in this page because even a #1 on its own isn't notable enough in the grand scheme).

Feel free to discuss this if you disagree.

- Hi. I mean The X Factor UK, not The X Factor only.

Okay, I can accept your second opinion.

Thank you. Grahap (talk) 06:14, 6 March 2017 (UTC)

-

Thanks for understanding where I was coming from. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Bennv3771 (talk • contribs) 09:01, 6 March 2017 (UTC)

April 2017
Hi. Please note that it is misleading to use "more than" when the source says "nearly" as in this edit on Little Mix. They have different meanings. Thanks. Bennv3771 (talk) 14:23, 5 April 2017 (UTC)