User talk:Haielu

Nermed
Hi, I see you reverted the Nermed article to your version about the village. My main problem with that is that the article was about a river, and it can't be about a river and a village at the same time. I suggest you create a new article Nermed (village) and place your content in that article. If you want I can help you with the Wikidata links, the infobox etc. Some other issues:
 * You write that the Croatian name is Nermiđ, while Croatian Wikipedia calls it Neremić. Do you have a reference for your version?
 * The reference you use for the claim that 98% of the population are Catholic (edc.ro) does not give information on the village level, only for the commune Carașova
 * Do you have a reference for the claim that the population are (mostly) Croats? It is likely, but it could theoretically be that all ethnic Romanians of the commune Carașova live in this village. I only see ethnic data on commune level, not on village level.

Markussep Talk 08:53, 17 July 2021 (UTC)


 * Hi, thanks for reaching out to me! I would like this to be the main page about the village and not about the river as the river is less likely to be researched or looked upon by anyone. Furthermore the page about the river contains very little information and will most likely never get updated. This could be solved easily, by either creating a new article called Nermed (tribunary) or by just simply implementing the tribunary inside the village wiki.
 * The Croatian name is indeed Nermiđ and not Neremić. It may have been called by that name before, but it changed. If you actually visit the village, or go near Carasova which also contains traffic signs leading to Nermed it clearly shows an extra sign with the Croatian Name Nermiđ.
 * The population is indeed Catholic. The inhibitants are indeed mostly Croatians.
 * I am also willing to update the article according to the well archived Croatian wiki.
 * Haielu (talk) 22:46, 17 July 2021 (UTC)


 * Probably neither the river nor the village is the primary topic, so maybe the best solution is to turn Nermed into a disambiguation page, and have two articles Nermed (village) and Nermed (river). I'll do that when you've created the village article. You're probably right about the name, I found this website of the Croatian community in Romania and this website of the Roman catholic parish of Carașova. I guess we could use these as references for the Croatian name. You can't use (Croatian) Wikipedia as a reference (see WP:UGC), but if they mention a reference, you can look it up and use that. I see the Romanian Wikipedia article uses a reference that gives ethnic compositions on the village level: http://www.kia.hu/konyvtar/erdely/erd2002/etnii2002.zip, maybe that website also has other 2002 census data of interest. Markussep Talk 18:06, 18 July 2021 (UTC)