User talk:Hha03

Santa Rosa, California
Hi there, at Santa Rosa, California the sections were in proper order, per WP:USCITIES. You are welcome to expand the article, but no need to re-arrange sections. Thanks. Magnolia677 (talk) 10:22, 24 July 2020 (UTC)


 * Hi Magnolia677. Thanks for your comment. WP:USCITIES does not take a position on where information on police and fire departments should be included. However, as the examples of infrastructure provided there all have to do with physical structures (transportation, electric and water utilities and so on) rather than 'soft' infrastructure, I looked for guidance to FA-class articles for similar Mid-Importance cities in WikiProject_Cities. Articles like Erie, Pennsylvania, Kent, Ohio, and Hamilton, Ontario all list any information about police and fire departments under Government. Of the FA-class articles I looked through, none listed this information under Infrastructure. It may not therefore be a technically necessary edit by the bare guidance of WP:USCITIES, but I believe it improves the page by bringing it more in line with the format of the highest-rated articles on similar topics.


 * You only mentioned reverting my rearrangement of sections, but I see that you also reverted other edits which expanded the article. In the media section I added information about local radio stations and the Television Market Area. In the Government section I added information about the city charter and government entities, recent taxation and spending, and total number of government employees. All of this is information requested in WP:USCITIES. Why was this removed? It was flagged up as vandalism by ClueBot NG, but I have followed the instructions for reporting a false positive and reinstated the changes. If those edits have their own flaws, I'm happy to work on improving them, but I do first need to know what those flaws were. Thanks for your help.


 * Best, Hha03 (talk) 12:47, 24 July 2020 (UTC)
 * I reverted your edit. Please discuss your change on the article talk page and gain consensus.  I caution you not to edit war. Thank you. Magnolia677 (talk) 14:58, 27 July 2020 (UTC)

Magnolia wonder if you could have a look at the other edits you reverted? We need new editors and this is a bit of a negative response. YellowFratello (talk) 07:35, 28 July 2020 (UTC)