User talk:Ibaker5/Hadrian's Villa

Peer Review
Hi Izabela,

I appreciated your article as I felt it gave a new insight into the Wiki page for Hadrian's Villa. All of the critiques I have are very small! There are some sentences I would like to know more about. For example, in the first sentence, if you could find out why Hadrian began construction early in his career or how he was able to do so, or if this was uncommon for other emperors, that would be great. The second sentence is incomplete - though it was ongoing, x happened. The third sentence also begins with "though." When you stated, "the other evidence we have of Hadrian's villa in ancient writing," it makes it sound a bit like these ancient writings are proving its existence and as though there are no other ancient writings that discuss the Villa. Maybe this is what you are trying to say, but rather, I would phrase the sentence as "Hadrian named rooms of the villa after various significant locations within the Roman Empire (the Lyceum, the Academy, Hades) and these continue today to be the terms scholars use to describe sections of the villa (MacDonald 7)". Also, you need to include quite a few periods. Finally, I would expand a bit more at the end about the implications of this excavation and the impacts it has caused until this day. Also, we discussed the citations in person but just polishing those up! All of this information is super interesting, and I was intrigued reading it. Good job! Avamilazzo (talk) 13:50, 24 November 2022 (UTC)