User talk:Ilyon

Cradle of Filth
Stop removing Cradle of Filth from the list of black metal bands. They certainly are rooted in black metal and thus belong on this list. It's not a list of trve black metal bands only - otherwise many other bands would have to be removed as well. Spearhead 16:50, 6 December 2005 (UTC)

Your example is bullshit. A counter example is Metallica who started out as a speed/thrash band - now there nowhere near thrash but still listed as a prime example of thrash. CoF were BM from the start. In fact in many sources they're are listed as a black metal band. Eg. BNR Spearhead 21:29, 6 December 2005 (UTC)

Reply I totally agree with this

Cradle of Filth have all the Black Metal elements

Steve_69

WikiProject Music genres
Hi. I saw your extensive comments in the AfD list for various Metal genre articles. I don't know anything about Metal, but it got me thinking that you might be interested in joining WikiProject Music genres and setting up a sub-project for Metal. I don't really know anything about Wikiprojects either, but there are resources listed there. It would be good to try to get all this sorted out. It sounds complicated. Herostratus 15:29, 8 December 2005 (UTC)