User talk:InShaneee/Archive/Jun/2014

ProPakistani


I'm not sure, it is a borderline submission, but would you accept the submission now or does it fail under WP:1News?  mabdul (public) 12:49, 14 April 2013 (UTC)
 * Blah...I'm still not seeing anything directly about the site in any of the references. The PKNIC thing is definitely noteworthy, but I'm not sure that it justifies the whole article. I really wish Abuzarsajjad had gotten back to me about possible sources in Urdu, because I do get the feeling this site might be something within Pakistan and nearby, but googling in english just doesn't turn up anything but promotional sites for me. I specifically avoided the AfC because I don't want to look like judge, jury, and executioner here, but if it were me, I'd say this article still falls into the "almost there" pile. InShaneee (talk) 02:49, 15 April 2013 (UTC)


 * Yeah, I was really unsure about that article and thought something like "AGF, borderline, but AGF", but when moving/accepting the page protection stopped me. I really need to add a warning to the tool checking the deletion log. This would really help even experienced editors!
 * Thanks, I will decline it now. mabdul 05:24, 15 April 2013 (UTC)


 * Sir If you see ProPakistani Rank 65th in Pakistan and 7,020 worldwide . 90.6% visitors are from Pakistan. In technology ProPakistani is first website in mind in Pakistan. Afterwards many International and National Newspapers, TV Channels like BBC, Express Tribune , Telegraph also used their reporting stories. I Know this is not a proper Reason for Article creation. I was not promoting ProPakistani, I have no link with ProPakistani.


 * At 3G technology auction ProPakistani also reported entire event there was 1,850 Comments.


 * This story is in Urdu It's clear that BBC named Aamir Attaa (ProPakistani Founder) as Pakistan's IT Expert. May be you say all of these points doesn't clarify the value of article but that website is widely appreciated in Pakistan. If you have any doubt Please check there social profiles on Twitter, Facebook


 * This is a late reply because I see this today. Muhammad Abuzar Sajjad (talk) 13:22, 16 June 2014 (UTC)