User talk:Inwaterpeace

Alicia Alighatti
I have removed your insertion of her "real name" on WP:BLP grounds. As stated in the real names section of WP:P*, we must provide a solid source for the name, and the consensus is that IMDB's bio page does not count. And this view is held on high as well; I've traded emails with Jimbo Wales on the topic and know he's of the same opinion (see Talk:Mason Marconi for his comments). Tabercil (talk) 00:15, 7 February 2008 (UTC)

I gave you a solid source (http://www.guilford.edu/sports/WLX/2003/HTML/gc-lc.htm). Consider this: 1) you do not challenge that she was an equestrian; 2) you do not challenge that she attended Lynchburg College. Therefore, Murdoch's listing on this page is proof. Furthermore, to "vet" someone is to verify their credentials. You are playing a semantics game. Lastly, for what it's worth, I knew Ellie in college. I'm sorry that you don't think her real name is "sexy enough," but it is her name and there is ample proof. Hell, call the college and confirm her attendance. —Preceding unsigned comment added by Inwaterpeace (talk • contribs) 20:56, February 6, 2008


 * Oh I'm not questioning that Ms. Murdoch was at Lynchburg - though the listing you're giving is for a lacrosse box score, not for equestrian events. What I am challenging you on is your contention that Ellie and Alicia are one and the same. All we have is your word - which falls exactly into the category of original research and furthermore is not independently verifiable. I've said it before and I'll say it again... per Wikipedia's biography of living people policy, we need solid facts from reliable sources. Until you provide them, the information will not be allowed into the article. Tabercil (talk) 05:54, 12 February 2008 (UTC)