User talk:Islandbay/Calculator apps

While I see no reason why an article like this is an obvious candidate for WP:AfD, I would like to provide some feedback on what will make it more likely to stand up. First, make sure you have adequate citations in reliable sources. Articles like this are often criticized for failing to meet the notability standard. Citing other WP pages or press releases are not enough. I think a fair test would be whether you could find an article in CNET or Engadget similar publication. If not, then the topic probably isn't mature enough for an article. Also, please be careful about adding links indiscriminately which you appear to have done (a common newbie mistake). If you persist, the offending links might be added to the spam blacklist. Good luck, I'd be happy to offer more advice or answer any additional questions. Ronnotel (talk) 13:24, 26 October 2009 (UTC)