User talk:Jc-S0CO/Archives/2007/8

3RR/Rktect
Replied at my talk. Raymond Arritt 02:17, 2 August 2007 (UTC)

your reverts
(cur) (last) 15:01, August 2, 2007 Jc-S0CO (Talk | contribs) (80,670 bytes) (Undid revision 148773695 by user:Rktect: Please. It says right on the front page "review comments...are not to be represented as results of the IPCC assessment.") (undo)

Look at the date on the front page. These June 15, 2006 comments were incorporated in the 2007 report making it possible to cite them from the 2007 report and reference back to the fact that they derived from comments made in 2006. I pointed out that they were incorporated in the report. They should be in the article.Rktect 23:48, 2 August 2007 (UTC)


 * If you can find these statements in the report itself, then you may have something to build off of. But that does not change the fact that the comments themselves are specifically labelled with a message saying not to associate them with the final report. References to the comments are not valid as a source. ~ S0CO ( talk 02:07, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
 * I want to emphasize that User:Jc-S0CO is absolutely correct here. Comments were open to anyone who wanted to make them; some were off-the-wall or unconstructively tendentious. The only possible use for the comments is to attribute the views of an individual, e.g., "John Smith, in his comments on the IPCC AR4, claimed...", and even then I'm not altogether convinced. Raymond Arritt 02:13, 3 August 2007 (UTC)

User:68.15.226.72
Earlier today this user left me a message on my talk page and then told me if i have any problems with it to talk to you and left a link to this talk page. But because it was a diffrent user name I am just wondering is this ip adress you? (on my talk page User talk:joseph_098 the edit is still on top if you wish to check). If this is you i will talk more about why i made the edit to the article that is in question from the origonal message
 * Yes, this is me. I was just curious why the message appeared on the IP talk page when you had not reverted any of my edits to Ariel (Firefly episode). ~ S0CO ( talk 13:24, 22 August 2007 (UTC)


 * I know I did revert something on that page, but the previous version have been deleted so unfortunately I can not tell now what I changed but if it was legitimate, I am sorry for any inconvenience it caused.Joseph 098 21:04, 22 August 2007 (UTC)