User talk:Jd2718/jd2718 ArbCom notes

Good start
Nice to see someone else attempting this! Thanks for the note over at my version. I'm considering doing mine as a table, as that will look better. I want to add stuff like "date of account creation" (as you've done), "date becoming admin (if one)" (as you've done), plus "date of nomination for ArbCom election", and "previous candidate in ArbCom election?" and "previous member of ArbCom?". Stuff like that. And also look at the block log for the candidates to see if they have ever been blocked. What do you think? Carcharoth 18:04, 25 November 2006 (UTC)

Wow! Good job
I like this page and your reasoning. I wish everyone did pages like this. I think I'll do something similar, giving a list of my criteria, but I won't give a list of which candidates I opposed or supported, and the reasons, until after the elections, as I want to link to the page from my votes, but not sway others opinions - merely show them how I think they should make up their own minds. I'm also going to add a criteria to my list of whether I have encountered the candidate before, or whether the candidate is (to me) an unknown. Carcharoth 11:40, 4 December 2006 (UTC)

Some corrections
MONGO's has now restored his userpage. Quite an interesting history there. Carcharoth 13:46, 13 December 2006 (UTC)

2007 stuff
Hi there. Thanks for the note. I'll be following the elections, but probably not as closely as last time. I hope someone does do a table like last time, but I won't have time right now to take part in editing anything like that. I will be reading what you come up with though, as I often find myself agreeing with your assessments. Carcharoth 01:12, 11 November 2007 (UTC)