User talk:Jimbow123

Hi,

I saw you deleted the stuff about Mr. Shotyk's "contribution to science". Admittedly he didn't publish anything really new in JEM. But what he did do is give a bunch of scare-mongering interviews to the English speaking press based on his results, which he claimed to be new and alarming and a reason to shun PET bottles. Unfortunately the Swiss BAG assessment is not in English and thus not easily accessible to English-speaking readers. Thus it's likely that someone will come back and add Mr. Shotyk's alarmism (again). Wouldn't it be better to leave a reference to Mr. Shotyk in the article, but put it in perspective?

CindyB 16:17, 1 January 2007 (UTC)

Well, as I predicted, your removal of the reference to Mr Shotyk's "terrible poison in PET bottled water" alarmism, prompted some anonymous person to add the alarmism again. I've reverted the section to the version before your change.

CindyB 15:43, 4 February 2007 (UTC)