User talk:JohnMink

Welcome to Wikipedia. We invite everyone to contribute constructively to the encyclopedia. However, the external links you added do not comply with our guidelines for external links. Wikipedia is not a mere directory of links; nor should it be used for advertising or promotion. Since Wikipedia uses nofollow tags, external links do not alter search engine rankings. If you feel the link should be added to the article, then please discuss it on the article's talk page before reinserting it. Please take a look at the welcome page to learn more about contributing to this encyclopedia. Spiesr 13:13, 17 April 2007 (UTC)

External Links...
I suggest that you read WP:SPAM. I deleted these links because they promote a service/product. (Nonprofit or not that is still spam.)) If they had been on a page which they had relevant information for, such as an article about the service itself, they could have stayed, but they did not contain relevant information about the articles from which they were removed. Spiesr 16:44, 18 April 2007 (UTC)

Thank you for the response. With all due respect, however, these links are not spam. There is no specific promotion of a service/product, there is nothing to sell through the site - all the images are under creative commons licenses for public and educational use. Cyark is supported by grants from national institutions, NGOs, site authorities, and educational institutions. People are paid to perform the work, but people are paid to perform academic research as well - and the pay for Cyark work comes from the same sources that power academic research, primarily public ones. By your logic, all academic research is also promoting a service/product, and in this case the product is knowlegdge and unfiltered information. If you really wish to exclude professional academic research and knowledge production from wikipedia, including that which is freely available to the public, then what is left?

Enthusiastic amateur sites, such as the one you left up for Tikal at http://www.authenticmaya.com/authentic_maya.htm, are still used as promotional sites (in this case, to sell rum and site tours) and, in addition, do not even have trasparency as to their affiliations and references. In short, they are not academic, though they may be adequate. Even "official" government sites, such as the national park of Tikal site, are involved in selling a promotion or service - getting tourists to visit the site.

Again, I'm not sure you even looked at the links I put up, but they led to sites with nothing but a series of enlargeable thumbnails containing detailed architectural, photographic, three-dimensional, and panoramic images of the park with commentary from site authorities and academic researchers. There was no service for sale, there is no "product" per se beyond publicly available archival information, and the direct links I put up did not even have any indication of the identity of Cyark or its mission unless you chose to search to the root website - mainly because Cyark's purpose is education and the application of new technologies (that we do not sell) in its service, not moneymaking. I would like to put these links back up because I feel they would be of use to those who wish to gain access to detailed archival images and maps of these World Heritage Sites, and I feel these are relevant links to the sites themselves. I would, however, be happy to remove the reference to Cyark in the links themselves and simply refer to them as Mapping, Hi-Definition Data Capture, Photographic, Panoramic, and 3D Imaging sites.

--John Mink, Cyark Intern (I am using the Cyark wikipedia ID to afford a measure of transparency)


 * Fine, put the links back up. On a differnt note, remeber to sign messages on talk pages by typing ~ as this links to your userpage. Spiesr 22:12, 23 April 2007 (UTC)

Regarding your username
While I realize you have an affiliation with cyark.org, Wikipedia's username policy prohibits usernames that "match the name of a well-known company or group (especially if the user promotes it)". Fortunately, it is possible to apply for a username change. If you would like to discuss this matter, I can be contacted at my talk page. Thank you. +A.0u 02:23, 24 April 2007 (UTC)

Ok, changed it
Thanks for the heads-up.

Authnticmaya.com
With all Your respect, My site does not promote any product or service, I don't know where You find ""Rum and Coke" or any service for tourist in my entire website, I only inform the facilities in Tikal, That by the way do not include selling any alcoholic beverages, and neither mention any tour operator, only the fee for the park, musseum and transport from Flores to Tikal. Please be more polite when you refer to sites that You obviously does not have read, even superfiacilly.

mayasautenticos 18:33, 26 September 2007 (UTC)Authenticmayamayasautenticos 18:33, 26 September 2007 (UTC)