User talk:Josve05a/disclosure

I'm told this is meant to help users having problems with Terms_of_use. Thanks for trying! It's indeed a pity that so many users are unwillingly made into criminals. There are however several problems. I leave aside the issue of en.wiki policies (as regards user pages editing) and of other parts of ToU. --Nemo 15:33, 18 November 2014 (UTC)
 * 1) The part "or believed to have a conflict of interest" serves no purpose for the ToU.
 * 2) ToU ask disclosure of "employer, client, and affiliation with respect to any contribution for which you receive, or expect to receive, compensation". Without saying who is compensating, any disclosure is useless for the ToU's sake.
 * 3) ToU also says "you". I don't think "you" means "you or someone acting in your place as if they were you (by editing your user page)". Of course the meaning of "you" could be changed, but en.wiki would need to adopt an alternative disclosure policy.