User talk:Jssherkow

William Renner
I have reread the article and I am still of the opinion that William Renner is at this time non notable. At this time he is not actually standing for office and may never do so. The article stated that "Renner is now currently working in Chicago, Illinois developing the skills he will require to one day make Maine an economic powerhouse." He could, therefore, decide to stay there and never return to Maine or stay long enough that he would not be the youngest Governor. However, if he should run then it's possible that he would qualify for a Wikipedia article.

To answer "We believe that the deletion of a gubernatorial candidate's life-biography from Wikipedia for non-notable status, with clear political motivation, is a blatant violation of the neutrality premise behind Wikipedia." This is simply not true. The man is not at this time a candidate. All he has said is that one day he may be one. He appears to have no particular political affiliation at this time so there can be no "political motivation" or violation of neutrality on my part. Also, as the article was about people in Maine and I live in the Candadian Arctic it's unlikely that I would be motivated to delete people from a different country who would possibly be considering running for office. CambridgeBayWeather (talk) 01:01, 9 November 2005 (UTC)