User talk:Klas Grönqvist

Pachelbel
Thanks for adding the link and, of course, for compiling the list. Pachelbel is one of my favorite composers, and the catalogue situation is kind of bad. You should check the article List of compositions by Johann Pachelbel, which provides the same information as your list (i.e. several catalogues in one), except the editions. It is organized by genre. Also, if you need Welter's dissertation, e-mail me using Wikipedia's "E-mail this user" feature and we'll see what we can do about it.

Also, which works do you mean in your list by "works I know about, though not listed by Perreault"? I only know of the two keyboard fantasias found sometime in 2006 or so. --Jashiin (talk) 17:44, 7 February 2010 (UTC)

Thank you for the comments. Other works not in Perreault are: Ach Herr, wie ist meiner Feinde so viel: There is a recording of this work, but I don't know why Perreault doesn't mention it; a recent discovery or a spurious work? Bleibt es denn nun also: A recent discovery? Deinem Namen sei ewig Ehr’: A lost work? Fugue G major: It's not easy to keep works with the same title apart, but I got the impression that Tsukamoto has given two different works the same number. The fugue in question is recorded by Joseph Payne on Centaur CRC 2481 track 5, the incipit doesn't seem to fit with any G major fugue in Perreault. Mag ich Unglück nicht widerstahn: WPC 118. I have no further information. Nachdem die Treue Pflicht: A recent discovery? Wenn wir in höchsten Nöten sein: T L33/WPC 406: I have no further information. '''Wohl Erffurd! wohl, wohl dir''': A recent discovery?

I hardly need to see Welter's dissertation for other reasons than to check if Perreault's concordances are correct. Unfortunately, the proofreading of Perreault's book could have been better. Just an example: On p.335, edition STW, entry nr. 14 should be P 34, not 14; and entry 22 is P 503, not 504. In the case of books and editioms I haven't seen, I of course have to trust Perreault's data, which you obviously not always can. A strange fact is also that some Perreault numbers have two different WPC numbers, and vice versa.

It's virtually impossible to get everything correct in a list like this, so I'm thankful for any corrections or comments. I'll correct any wrongs in my list consecutively in the future.

Is there still another list of Pachelbel's works in progress? I found that Bärenreiter in its web page listes the Magnificats in vol. 4 av "PWV 1505", "PWV 1501" and "PWV 1502" respectively! Klas Grönqvist (talk) 16:49, 8 February 2010 (UTC)