User talk:Lizmtay/Psychology of music preference

Peer Review
Hi! I published my peer-review of your draft, but I am posting it here too for you in case this is easier for you to access! I hope it is helpful!

General info

 * Whose work are you reviewing?

User:Lizmtay


 * Link to draft you're reviewing
 * User:Lizmtay/Psychology of music preference


 * Link to the current version of the article (if it exists)
 * Psychology of music preference

Evaluate the drafted changes
I think that the source that you have added here is very relevant to the topic, but it could be helpful to spend a little bit of time on PsychInfo, google scholar, the UAB library, or another database looking for peer-reviewed secondary literature. Meta-analyses and systematic reviews are especially great sources for Wikipedia articles.

I also noticed that many of the facts listed in the first few sentences were not cited. I think that it could be helpful to find a few sources to document that music impacts cognitive development and facilitates self-expression as stated.

You have stated that personality differences do not account for much of the variance in music preference. Perhaps you could explore the factors that have been found to account for some of the variance in music preference and include a few sentence on that as well.

Additionally, I think that it could be helpful to remove the phrase "mostly using personality from the following sentence:

Numerous studies have been conducted to show that individual personality can have an effect on music preference, mostly using personality, though a recent meta-analysis has shown that personality in itself explains little variance in music preferences.

Peytonmk (talk) 05:32, 18 February 2024 (UTC)