User talk:Lukmat16

It was basically because you were not cooperative. You didn't use edit summaries, you didn't provide citations for your information, you ignored my warnings and you did not respond on my talk page. These are all signs of a typical misinformation vandal. Anyway, your source is a book that mixes movie stuff with book stuff. It seems like a great resource for more depth in the battles but I really don't know how accurate it is to what the book was implying. The information in the article basically has information derived solely from the books not the movies. Your information can be added but not at the expense of deleting info from books that have been around for decades. Gdo01 22:47, 3 March 2007 (UTC)

Ok sorry I suppose you're are right I just want to point out that Minas Tirith is not smaller in the movies than in the book. I just want to repeat what I've already wriiten. Fonstad says in the Atlas of Middle-Earth that the whole city has diameter of 3100 feet, not just the first level. So this information is not correct. The thing with 2800 men that came from the south is in the book (page 753) and in the atlas of middle earth.