User talk:Mabuska/Sources

The origination of Irish republicanism
As Domer48 changed their arguement to be on about republicanism originating from the Volunteers the following quotes are relevant to the discussion (both are from an academic Irish history encyclopedia):

The above two sources should put into context that there are twokinds of republicanism - pre-modern that permits a constitutional monarchy and modern anti-monarchy. To suggest a pre-modern republican thinker is the same as a modern republican thinker is synthesis and a post hoc ergo propter hoc assumption.

Where the Volunteers republicans?
This section lists one of Domer48's sources that helps contradict the assertion they are implying with some of the later quotes they use that because the republican United Irishmen were created from the remains of the Volunteers, that they too must be a republican organisation (a post hoc ergo propter hoc assumption). The above quote on republicanism also shows quite clearly that at the founding of the United Irishmen, they weren't modern Irish republicans but that at a later time they became so.

Sources that mention Volunteers
The following sources do make mention of the Volunteers.