User talk:Madmadmaddii

Joan Crawford
Please stop editing the birth year for Joan Crawford, as the reasons for the 1905 inclusion have already been explained in the revision history. While the birth year has been disputed, the cited birth year is 1905. Also, as another user mentioned, the footnote discusses the reasoning behind why 1905 is included. If you would like to debate the issue further, please use the article's talk page instead of editing the birth year again.

-- Luke4545 20:12, 31 December 2007 (UTC).


 * As above.... I appreciate that 1906 is given as the birth year at www.legendaryjoancrawford.com, but the fact is that her birth date is given differently at several different sites, so to just pick that one and say that it's correct because it's on that site, isn't right.  There are at least 4 birth dates used by different sources, but after discussion it was decided that 1905 was the date the had the strongest supporting evidence as it was taken from a US Census Record of 1910, and that should be more accurate and reliable than a fan site that doesn't clearly explain where the birthdate was taken from.   Please stop changing the date.  Thanks (www.legendaryjoancrawford.com is an absolutely beautiful site by the way, and is one of the best of its kind that I've seen) Rossrs (talk) 00:55, 1 January 2008 (UTC)