User talk:Marvick2001

Unless you can identify - to the second!'- where on the released version Lennon sings this line, then it remains a ridiculous and unsubstantiated myth. I don't doubt they may have added that line on another take - but on the released version unless you can prove otherwise, Lennon and indeed no-one else sings "baby you're a rich, fag, Jew"


 * Er, I meant the article talk page ... FYI, here's one of the five core Wikipedia policies (with emphasis added by me where it seemed especially relevant): "We strive for articles that document and explain major points of view, giving due weight with respect to their prominence in an impartial tone. We avoid advocacy and we characterize information and issues rather than debate them. In some areas there may be just one well-recognized point of view; in others, we describe multiple points of view, presenting each accurately and in context rather than as "the truth" or "the best view". All articles must strive for verifiable accuracy, citing reliable, authoritative sources, especially when the topic is controversial or is on living persons. Editors' personal experiences, interpretations, or opinions do not belong." JG66 (talk) 11:33, 12 July 2017 (UTC)

Agreed - then verify the authoritive source that PROVES that Lennon sings this. Just indentify on the released track (at the precise minute and second) where he sings the line? It's impossible because he doesn't.


 * You seem quite ignorant of how to go about things here. But fair enough – you haven't received a Welcome message, which outlines a few important things about Wikipedia, including those core principles I mentioned above. On the other hand, in one of my reverts, I referred you to WP:BRD, which is usually very effective since it brings other editors into the issue – instead, you start a discussion here, not on the article talk page (accompanied by a further revert in the article). You're edit-warring (as am I in reverting your change each time, but at least I have sources to back my position; you have nothing), and I can only think you're heading straight for a "block". Also, is it not even clear after this change by me that Lennon's altering of the line could well have happened in other vocal takes, not the final one? Just as the text later mentions how the studio tapes reveal Lennon similarly teasing Jagger and Starr, but 'obviously' those comments don't appear on the completed track [either], do they? JG66 (talk) 13:50, 12 July 2017 (UTC)