User talk:Melody Concerto/Archives/1-8-15

Category:User Talk:Melody Concerto Archive
Category:User Talk:Melody Concerto Archive, which you created, has been nominated for possible deletion, merging, or renaming. If you would like to participate in the discussion, you are invited to add your comments at the category's entry on the Categories for discussion page. Thank you. DexDor (talk) 05:13, 29 December 2014 (UTC)

I don't believe your reason for the deletion is proper or will stand, you only specify that "We don't do this as far as I know" and does not appear to be a proper or legitimate reason for deletion. Melody Concertotalk 07:02, 29 December 2014 (UTC)

Re: CfD nomination
moved from Category talk:User Talk:Melody Concerto Archive 03:38, 27 September 2015 (UTC)

The reasoning provided for this category deletion is thin. Merely a "We don't do that" should not suffice to delete any article unless such things are blatantly against some policy outlined in the proper namespace. Melody Concertotalk 07:06, 29 December 2014 (UTC)

I contend that since the page isn't directly a userpage, just a talk page, that WP:NOUSERCAT does not apply. Were I applying the category directly to User:Melody_Concerto this may indeed apply.

Per WP:PROJCATS I contend the category is administrative and has never pretended to be a content category, it is useful for finding my talk archives. While I may not yet have a million of them, there's nothing in current policy that precludes the use of such categories on TALK pages. If other editors wish to move for a rename, that would be acceptable, but current policies being cited don't really seem to cover this specific instance and I feel further discussion and consensus should be required because I still disagree with the original rationale for this CfD being "We don't do that here" in so many words. Melody Concertotalk 00:28, 31 December 2014 (UTC)


 * The CFD nomination does not propose to delete any articles. WP:NOUSERCAT does not specifically refer to user talk pages (maybe it should), but the general rule is that talk pages are less in need of categorization than the corresponding non-talk pages (e.g. "there is no need to categorize talk pages, redirects, or user pages, though ...") as the main way to navigate to a talk page is by clicking on the "Talk" tab. DexDor (talk) 08:00, 31 December 2014 (UTC)