User talk:Memphians in Support of David Saks

It looks like a potential confrontation is beginning. Why not http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Requests_for_comment/Art%2C_architecture%2C_literature_and_media submit a request for comment to determine if David Saks is notable enough for Memphis? Focus on David Sacks' work and why it's important (or not important), not the other person editing Wikipedia. Archtransit (talk) 21:02, 2 February 2008 (UTC)

Please e-mail me at aeroarch@hotmail.com or enable your email. I'd like to give you some advice on possible amicable resolution of this problem and editing advice. If this problem isn't resolved, you could be blocked by someone else. This won't help. Archtransit (talk) 17:08, 4 February 2008 (UTC)

Memphians in Support of David Saks (talk) 09:25, 5 February 2008 (UTC)

David Saks is the Composer of the Official Songs of Memphis
The recognition of David Saks was an honor presented to him that was of a distinctly greater degree than is commonly the nature of the Memphis City Council. It was a tangible symbol signifying the approval of this gentlemans' contributions to the community. The compulsive deletion, sabotage and tag-teaming of this entry by a few has become personal and vicious. Any attempt to suppress the input of any entry without an account is ludicrous, derisory and prejudicial. Mr. Saks deserves to be recognized honorably within the article. Jersyko is arrogant and self-opinionated. Thank you for a reasonable attitude toward the discussion of Mr. Saks, Archtransit. User Jersyko is impervious to reason and has waged a personal war against any entry recognizing either Mr. Saks' honor or the fact that the two songs composed by Mr. Saks' are, indeeed, the only two songs ever adopted by the city government as the official songs of Memphis. We are not the user User:Reneec this disgruntled admin is referring. My wife and I know of Mr.Saks. He is a remarkable and kind person who would take great offense at any attempt to dishonor or discredit him in such fashion that jersyko has instigated. The Memphis, Tennessee archive demonstrates that Mr. Saks has forwarded requested documentation from the Memphis City Council demonstrating that the awards were legitimate. It was not good enough for jersyko. I would ask that jersyko and his editing privileges be given careful scrutiny by a body of peers. Not cronies that remorselessly and pitilessly tag team and destroy worthy entries like vandals. We discovered that the legal threat that this disatisfied user refers is an entry that User:Reneec made many months ago when she discovered that jersyko was a law student at the University of Memphis. The user, Reneec, suggested that a call to the Deans Office at the University of Memphis, to determine whether or not Jersyko was indeed who he said he was, could be inferred to be as ridiculous as a suggestion that Jersyko and another, User:Scribner, made that Mr. Saks should be called to inquire whether or not Mr. Saks was given the award by the government or if he asked the government for the award, an insidious attempt to insult Mr. Saks. Jersyko believed that User:Reneec, who had discovered his real identity, was going to call the law school dean, and vigorously campaigned to have user Reneec banned from Wikipedia. User:Reneec never published User:Jersyko real identity out of respect for him, even after she was banned. Jersyko's behavior, along with others, was unjustifiable and an act of oppression towards a new user. Please read the archives. Jersyko was never threatened. Thank you again, Archtransit. Vindication for Mr. Saks may be possible with a kindly and thoughtful attempt towards resolution. Compulsive deletion, and tag-teaming, deliberate destruction of the entry regarding David Saks as the composer of the only "Official Songs of Memphis" has become personal with a problematic user, Jersyko, who compulsively, and with somewhat seditious and incitive or rabble-rousing fashion, as noted by editing comments, removes entries pertaining to Mr. Saks' work. User Jersyko, within the last two years, had one user, Reneec, inexecusably banned because of her support of David Saks and, in paranoid fashion, removed personal information about himself as a law student at the University of Memphis while falsely alleging that the user had threatened him with bodily harm. "One Last Bridge," written by native Memphian, composer and pianist David Saks, was adopted and proclaimed in unanimous resolution (11-0) by the Memphis City Council as Memphis' Official Song of 1990. His composition, "In Memphis", was adopted as an Official Song of Memphis, the following year in City Council session, in 1991. These are the only two musical compositions ever adopted as Official Songs of Memphis. The record of the Memphis City Council has been reviewed, confirmed many times, is notable and well documented. Refer to the archives for additional information.Memphians in Support of David Saks (talk) 17:41, 5 February 2008 (UTC)

Ambiguous Reasons for Denial
Stifle is off base with the denial. A denial to edit whose expression cannot be determined from it's context is prejudicial. Because we failed to sign in does not imply that sock puppetry has been perpetrated, nor any more so than the allegation that the user name is inappropriate or "disruptive".