User talk:Micheldardenne1999

Sockpuppetry case
Your name has been mentioned in connection with a sockpuppetry case. Please refer to Sockpuppet investigations/Roosevelt234 for evidence. Please make sure you make yourself familiar with the guide to responding to cases before editing the evidence page. Favonian (talk) 15:59, 24 April 2012 (UTC)

On page http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aisha one can read a statement that prophet Mohammed married Aisha when she was six or nine years old. There is only one hadith stating this, in both Muslim and Bukhari collections, and, in the light of the actual pedophilia scandals, it this is not sufficient to accuse the Prophet. Other authentic hadiths and the history do exclude this early age as a possibility. History: The suspected marriage happened in year 1 (hijra calendar), in the month of Shawal, after the first month of Ramadan when the mosque was finished (source: Mokhtasar Sirat Ar-rasul, p. 80, Mohammed Ibn Abdulwahâb). Sister Asmaa was 10 years older than Aisha. She died in year 73 (hijra calendar) when she was 100 years old. A simple calculation puts Asmaa's birth in -27, so Aisha's in -17. Hadiths collector Mishkat al-Masabih, Iman Wali ud-Din Muhammad Ibn Abdullah Al-Khatib, wrote about Asmaa, Abu Bakr's oldest daughter : « She was Aisha's sister, the holy Prophet's wife, and she was ten years older. In the year 73, Asmaa died at the age 100. » (Mishkat al-Masabih, p. 300-301 in the Urdu edition). Ibn Kathir, famous and classic commentator of the Qur'an has said the same: « Asmaâ died in the year 73 of hijra at the age of 100. She was 10 years older than her sister Aisha. » (Al-Bidayya wa-l-Nihaya, Vol. 8, p. 346.) Hadiths : Hadiths relate questions that some people asked to Aisha, about the religion at her parents' home. « Did your parents always practice religion ? », some asked. Now, think just a minute. If Aisha was 9 when she consummated the marriage, 13 years after the beginning of the revelation, when her parents and her sister did convert, why question her about souvenirs dating 4 years... before she was born ? This is ridiculous. And she answered ! « As far as I can remember, my parents always practiced the religion. » (Sahih Boukhârî nr.476) Would she have answered about souvenirs dating 13 years before her marriage, if she was only 9 when she got married ? Several hadiths mention that Aisha played with dolls, when she got engaged at age 6. Not only is age 6 a little young for girls to play with dolls, but the hadiths state that she manufactured the dolls herself. The Prophète asked her about a specific doll, a horse with wings. « A horse with wings ? », he asked. « didn't you hear that Soulayman's horses had wings ? » The Prophet laughed and Aisha saw his teeth, deep in his mouth (Bukhari : Politeness, n°6130 - Mouslim : vertues of the companions, n°2440 – Abudawad : politeness, n°4931 – Ibnou Maja : the marriage, n°1982 – Iman Ahmed : Musned, 6/234). Does a 6 years old girl have a conversation like this ? Can a 6 year old girl manufacture dolls herself ? A horse with wings ? This is absolutely unbelievable ! Age and other numbers are relative and need the context. When I say I am born in 59, will you believe it ? Or will you rather believe I was born in 59 "after 1900" ? Same for Aisha : she was 6 when she got engaged, 9 when she got married, "after something", not necessarily "after birth". In these times, births were not registered and the age was often given "after first period". Before accusing, you must have proof. Otherwise, I would like to invite you to be a little more polite and careful with your statements. The french version of your article contains even more references, click 'français' left of your article. http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/A%C3%AFcha#.C3.82ge_d.27A.C3.AFcha_lors_de_son_mariage May God reward you for your kindness.