User talk:Mkativerata/Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Baxter Healthcare

Excerpts from dissenting judgments
I don't see the problem with these excerpts. The excerpts are from the critical passages of Kirby and Callinan's judgments. The article as currently written only gives very brief explanations of the dissenting judges' reasons, which contrasts unfavourably with (a) the more detailed explanation of the majority's reasons; and (b) the length and detail of Kirby and Callinan's judgments themselves. The reader needs to understand more about why Kirby and Callinan went the way that they did. --Broncos1988 (talk) 22:12, 22 December 2010 (UTC)