User talk:Mrothroc/Evaluate an Article

Read carefully - I think you're missing some significant problems with this page. There's an entirely empty section (Discoveries). Why is a page on history broken up into sections on enzymes and metabolism? Does Glycolysis warrant its own section and in an article on history, why are there no dates mentioned in this section? The talk page points out that genetic code is listed as an area of biochem in the introduction but there is no history of it.

History of a discipline pages have an inherent difficulty in that is the page meant to be a history of the term, or a history of the entire discipline, and then what are significant markers in the discipline? Are all the ones that are on that page the most significant moments and discoveries in biochemistry?

By the way, I had a student thinking about working on this page two years ago and giving up entirely. --Drglheard (talk) 03:40, 4 February 2021 (UTC)