User talk:Myninjanate/sandbox

Erin's Peer Review
I think the inclusions of the Gamble House being in Back to the Future is a great way to create familiarity with those reading the article. However, I would change the title to "Gamble House in Modern Culture" and then discuss its inclusion in the movie. I also think that having a separate section for its tourism value would be a good addition to the article. Lastly, I think including a section talking about the significance of the Gamble House is very necessary, this would show the readers that it isn't just a regular house in Pasadena. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Erin troy (talk • contribs) 19:38, 7 February 2018 (UTC)

Article evaluation
I just evaluated the Wikipedia page about Citation.


 * Everything in the article is relevant to the topic of citation. The picture at the beginning of the article was a bit distracting at first, but it made sense later on.


 * The article is pretty neutral, considering that it is is on a subject that isn't very heavily debated. It's more of an objective and explanatory view on how to cite.


 * There aren't any viewpoints that I could find, the article is pretty good at staying neutral.


 * All of the citations that I clicked on are working links, and they are all relevant. I could see the connection and why the authors have used those sources.


 * Most of the facts are referenced with appropriate and reliable sources. Some of the facts are common knowledge, so they didn't have to cite them.  There is no bias, as this article is mainly stating facts about Citation.


 * I looked at the "view history" page, and the recent updates were within a month of when I stumbled upon this page. The page isn't missing anything that I could tell.


 * Most of the conversations consist of questions about citation and what types exist. It seems like an educational forum.


 * It is rated as Start-Class and High-Importance, which makes sense because most people need to know this, but it is basic info at the same time. It is part of the WikiProject Libraries and the WikiProject Science.


 * In class, we discuss the moral values that are tied with citation, such as giving credit to the author, whereas the article is more focused on citation and what it is in general.

Myninjanate (talk) 19:36, 9 January 2018 (UTC)