User talk:NKyoder/sandbox

Peer Review: Proposed Edits to Stone Cladding Article Article is appropriately neutral and provides a very general overview of the concept. Article might be restructured as a whole to accommodate the inclusion of contextual details.

Introduction/Lead I think it would be helpful for the article to be fleshed out with a strong introduction. - Is it possible to identify a point in history when stone cladding came into use? - Is there a particular installation system associated with this? - Is it associated with any particular architect or style? - Are there any notable sites that make use of stone cladding?

Merge with Stone Veneer It may be better to keep these topics separate, though there is a very interesting connection between them. - Could it be useful to explore reasons as to why cladding or veneer entered the industry lexicon? - Are cladding and veneer really the same? The articles seem to indicate that cladding has function while veneer is purely decorative. - Are there maybe materials/industry sources that help to define the two through comparison?

Reliable sources - The source currently listed: is there a difference between "stone cladding engineering" and "facade engineering"? - Does ASTM address this topic?

Drabaverna (talk) 05:38, 29 November 2018 (UTC)

Instructor comments
These draft edits are clearly a work in progress, but there should be more progress at this stage. The new references are heavily biased toward current construction industry websites; have you looked for offline references that are more generally about this building technology than about the specific products used therein? Illustrations (copyright-free or created yourself) would also be useful. Elizabeth Linden Rahway (talk) 00:48, 2 December 2018 (UTC)