User talk:Narval

French Revolution
I've responded at Talk:French Revolution, but since I also did some cleanup on that talk page, I am duplicating my remark here. If you want to respond, please do so at Talk:French Revolution. Thanks.

I don't think the problem is too much Mignet: it's too little anyone else. This article should give a broad range of opinion, and no one has gone through to add other historians' opinions. As you can see, where I retained opinionated remarks by Mignet, I was pretty careful to attribute them. NPOV doesn't mean we don't report opinions: it means that they are attributed (which they are) and balanced (which they won't be until someone else does something like the heavy lifting I did on this nearly three years ago)

Jmabel | Talk 19:40, 3 September 2006 (UTC)

I am passing some competitive entrance exam this week (Monday to Friday), but I'll put some stuff from Michelet and Furet ASAP. We need to avoid putting too much information coming from the "XIXth century" historians, though.