User talk:Nath1991/Archives/2009/February

Sydney FC - Patrick
Hi,

I notice you added Patrick back to the list of Notable Former Players on the Sydney FC article. Discussion on the talk page agreed that Patrick was not a former notable player - with no extensive contribution to the long term efforts of the team, not having played for any "major" clubs previously, and no international appearances for his country.

I'm going to remove him from the section as per the discussion on the talk page, if you think he should be included, can you please indicate your reasons on the article talk page and we can try to resolve it from there? Camw (talk) 06:33, 18 February 2009 (UTC)


 * I don't know that there are any standard rules, for example the EPL teams include players that have played more than 100 games for their club, as I assume listing internationally capped players would end up as a massive list. Being such a young league I guess we have more relaxed rules, but only 9 appearances for the club without significant notability outside of his time with Sydney is probably much too far on the low side for inclusion. I did see the good work you did updating the article, sorry for focusing on the negative and thanks for the other work. Camw (talk) 08:12, 18 February 2009 (UTC)

Bushmaster Protected Mobility Vehicle
I've just reverted your recent changes to this article as they involved removing large quantities of cited material without any explanation. Nick-D (talk) 04:32, 28 February 2009 (UTC)