User talk:Nick HIS

Aryan
Nick, you have repeatedly added the following passage to this page, and it has been repeatedly deleted:


 * New Persian writers often try and insist with over enthusiasm to show that the Persian language’s history starts with the arrival of “Aryans” to the land called Iran. But it is obvious to every one that in Persian history and literature, even in Persian national myths, until recently, there has been absolutely nothing about a tribe called “Aryan” and it has never been mentioned as an ethnicity in any Persian or other neighboring languages dictionaries. German Nazis who believed in “superior race” were the first who coined the “Aryan” word as an ethnic and racial concept as a concept to convey a full-blooded and noble by birth German. And after them this kind of usage got momentum and even some writers went to such an extreme that pretended that the history of Europe and most of Asia starts with Aryans. Thus, if there has been any other race and ethnic other than Aryan, they were ineffective and useless that they never left any trace from themselves and suddenly the origin of European and Asian civilization by the help of this new Orientalists’ magic came to the light from nowhere. This exorbitant idea which started in Nazi Germany and transmitted to Iran, in the second Pahlavis’s region reached its peak and had such an impact on the Shah that he called himself the light of Aryan. In addition Aryanism became the main pillar of Persian nationalist ideology which even after the collapse of the Pahlavi monarchy continued to survive. In such a manner that most Persian intellectuals are under its influence.

It has been deleted because it does not conform to academic standards in style and content. Indeed it makes statements that are generally accepted to be untrue. Persian 'national myths' most certainly do refer to Aryans, though perhaps not to a specific "tribe" as such. Where do you think the "land called Iran" got its name? Secondly "German Nazis" were not the first to use the word to convey the meaning "a full-blooded and noble by birth German". Please read the article fully before editing it. You may also wish to read the articles Aryan race and Nordic theory.Paul B 16:41, 29 March 2006 (UTC)

How much do you know about Iran's histoy? 1. In Iranian myth Qumarth had 2 sons Iraj and Tur, Iran actaully comes from Iraj: Iranj Offsring it doesn't mean "land called Iran". Turan or Turks are Tur's offspring. 2. There is nothing in Iranian myth like Shahnameh about Ayran tribe. 3. You maybe right about German Nazis and I need to investigate about it. Meanwhile have a look at this: www.myjavaserver.com/~sepulo/files/hadi-linguistic.pdf 4. As an admin, please do not mix "academic standards" with persian chuavinism.

Your report to WP:RFI
The users you reported were simply behaving as normal editors. Please see external link guidelines, taking note that it is not a good idea to add a link to your own websites/work. If you feel the link should be included add a note to the article's talk page asking another editor to review it and let them add it if they feel it is appropriate. The best place to discuss issues like this is by bringing them up on article talk pages, if you wish to question a particular editors edit then you can message them via their talk page. Cheers, Petros471 19:21, 29 March 2006 (UTC)

Many thanks for getting back to me. I just wanted to let you know that, that book is very well researched book about Aryan myth and Persian Racism and it really deserves to be there. You have no idea about the extent of Persian Nazism in Iran and among Persians abraod. I have added external link to other topics( ex christopher hitchens topic)but no one removed them. So is this a policy here that if some people do not like your view about a subject, remove it? Cheers