User talk:Oligerrish

Caresse Crosby
Welcome and thanks very much for your contributions to Wikipedia! I'm really reluctant to throw cold water on your contributions to Caresse Crosby. I can see you're really eager to help! But there are two important problems with the content you've added:


 * 1) The information you've provided about the Allardyce line and Caresse Crosby's ancestry which "included Plantagenet and Mediaeval Royal descents" does not rely on what Wikipedia describes as a reliable source. This is an essential foundation of Wikipedia -- being able to rely on the information provided as being supported by high quality primary and secondary sources.  The page you've cited in this (and prior) additions unfortunately does not qualify as a reliable source. It could qualify IF the sources cited met the criteria for a reliable source. But the sources cited refer to a single email from an an anonymous individual, or to an email from an unknown "Sean Cavanagh". The emails do not qualify as a primary, secondary or tertiary sources.
 * 2) While the royal connection might be inferred if the genealogical line could be traced back to these families, the information you added to in the Caresse Crosby article needs to be present in the source cited. The page you cite does not mention "Plantagenet and Mediaeval Royal" family connections.

I would very much like to support the conclusions you've made about the origins of the family. Can you find a reliable source to support them? — btphelps (talk to me) (what I've done) 18:20, 16 April 2014 (UTC)