User talk:Phatcat68/Archive Scott Mingus

Custer?

 * I'll second Hal's comments that a Custer category is not needed. A case in point - there are several other examples of ACW battles where Custer was prominent that are not listed in your category index (Hunterstown, Trevilian Station, etc). It would seem to be a lot of work to keep up with the category idea. Also, as Hal pointed out, Custer was a quite reknown ACW general, much better than an Indian fighter. There were times in the Civil War when his results matched his fabled self-image and confidence - few examples of this in the Indian wars. Scott Mingus 00:19, July 19, 2005 (UTC)