User talk:Pinkcyberheart

Hi, can you please explain, why you removed the content without any reason, we haven't copy/paste it from any site and we put this data with the reliable sources including references.

JS Group
Hi. I really appreciate your efforts to keep this article neutral; I'm particularly impressed that you caught this one: "In 2011, the AllWorld Network rated JS Group among the top 25 dynamic entrepreneurs in Pakistan." I've reviewed the sources, and you're absolutely correct. They seem to have been copresenters, not honorees.

But regardless of the truth of the matter, we do have to make sure that we do not slant it too much in the other direction. When allegations involve living people, we must be scrupulously correct in what we say to protect the Wikimedia Foundation and the Wikipedia community from legal issues. (See our biographies of living persons policy.) We can't imply, for instance, that there is some connection between JS Group's stock market performance and any land grabbing allegations, unless we have a source that says there is a connection. This is particularly true when there are sources that show that JS Group is actually a strong performer in relation to other companies. As per, it seems, "Jahangir Siddiqui Company was the volume leader at 10.6 million shares. It gained 3.78 percent to close at Rs7.13. Lotte Pakistan PTA saw trade in 9.1 million shares." Drawing our own implications from sourced facts is "synthesis", and it is forbidden by our "No Original Research" policy. If one source says they are having legal challenges and another source says their stocks are down, we can't connect those facts ourselves.

I hope you'll continue making sure that inflated claims do not make their way into publication on Wikipedia and that published information about the company (whether or positive or negative) is fairly represented. But, do, please, be careful that the information you add very accurately represents what those sources say. Thanks. --Moonriddengirl (talk) 11:59, 20 May 2011 (UTC)