User talk:Piteq

JMC, talk
WP:CIVIL, WP:NPOV, WP:OWN, WP:AGF, WP:RS, WP:NOT, WP:BITE, WP:NPA, WP:DE, WP:BITE

This user has a long history of incivility, tendentious editing, edit warring, and years of abuse of the revert function. This user has been repeatedly asked not to revert without discussion.

A recent attempt at mediation for making personal attacks between him and another user failed. There have been two third opinions in the last month.

Most recently this has been occurring at ARTICLE ARTICLE.


 * Removal of sourced NPOV information, without discussion: allegedly due to WP:NPOV: - is despite an explicit invitation to discuss the addition.


 * Violating WP:OWN "Try editing it down to points that have some connection with McCarthy's career and I'll reconsider it,"


 * WP:OWN: "There is already plenty of information about McCarthy's personal life in the article."


 * Applying a double standard in his edits: at McCarthyism an objectively unreferenced paragraph that is arguably WP:OR should in his view be retained with a waiting period (I agree to the waiting period).

Without an answer to these points, KB just adds back the information but only partially, moving it to the bottom (out of chronological order), and dropping a few things.
 * NB that much of the material in question seems to be notable enough to appear in the biographical articles about JFK, RFK, and Joseph Kennedy.


 * Asserting a widely referenced incident is "disputed" and reverting a reliably sourced mention of it: When invited to substantiate his claim that it is a "disputed" story with WP:RS: His reply is "do your own research."


 * WP:NPA: After denigrating these sourced additions as non-notable trivia, he posts,


 * This despite his history of 3RR blocks and a number of previous instances of tendentious editing on his part., also (this one substantiating both massive deletion of relevant info and personal attacks), also here  where a neutral 3rd opinion editor finds KB has been heavy handed and KB agrees to try to change his ways.