User talk:Rizzwan/Women in Hinduism

This page appears to be very unbalanced and even the references are mere names ,no links and not somthing that people can used to easily verify. The author uses highly subjective reasoning when discussing who is and is not wrong in thier translations of Sanskrit, a language very few people are even literate in. The manner of writing does not lend it towards being an objective insert into Wikipedia. T The opening statement is incorrect, the Manu-Smriti is not not an authoritative law book, it may have been at one time, but it is not for Hindus today. If that were so then the Hindu Law bill that applies to India's Hindus and therefore over 90% of the worlds Hindu population would entail the Manu Smriti. It does not.

the author talks about foetocide in India and the sex ratio, but does not look at Pakistan or several other non Hindu countries that have a sex-ratio imbalance en par.

In short this is shoddy work and needs objective input.--147.89.224.69 (talk) 14:48, 6 April 2009 (UTC)