User talk:Rubbersoul7

Re Scaruffi - there is an ongoing debate here on the merits of using these reviews. Until consensus is reached to change, status quo prevails and these should not be unilaterally removed. Please feel free to pitch in. -- Rodhullandemu  (Talk) 20:40, 16 April 2008 (UTC)
 * Just a word that edit comments such as "the album is far better than what they claim" and "The man clearly doesn't know anything about music" do seem to indicate that policy has passed you by. I appreciate there is a particular problem with Piero Scaruffi as a self-published source, but as one of the few critics to take issue with The Beatles' popularity - and give reasons for so doing - my view is that his reviews are usable; we should not be biasing articles one way or another, we should be placing material before our readers and allowing them to make up their own minds. -- Rodhullandemu  (Talk) 16:37, 27 April 2008 (UTC)