User talk:Rvsavo/sandbox

Please see me re progress on your article
Dear Mr Savo I thought you were going to write about AM and the Jews. I see no connection to the course topic here. I was not clear how you have changed the existing article. The revision page shows minimal edits. We need to check with Wikipedia editors re format of your footnotes. You have received 10 points so far and I will add the rest of the points when you are further along in your work. DH--DHertzGSR (talk) 13:47, 20 November 2018 (UTC)

Quite a bit of work left
Dear Mr Savo

I don't see what you are adding of significance to the original article. You have no mention here of his work called PORTRAIT OF A JEW. You seem to have several places where "ref" is in the textI am not entirely sure whether you are noting to yourself that you need a reference? Please clarify just exactly what you are adding to the original article. So far 15 points. DH--DHertzGSR (talk) 13:28, 27 November 2018 (UTC)

progress on your article
Dear Mr Savo

There is real progress here. Still need to compare your article to the existing article. Could you explain whether you are editing some portions and adding some portions? Your prose needs a lot of work. Please take this to the Teaching and Learning Commons for editing. Your academic footnotes are fine, although toward the end you seem to keep quoting the Jewish Social Studies article several times-I would fix that. So far, 15 points. Not ready to publish. DH--DHertzGSR (talk) 15:21, 4 December 2018 (UTC)

Continue your work on wiki article
--DHertzGSR (talk) 03:39, 14 December 2018 (UTC)Dear Mr Savo

Almost every sentence here has one problem or another. Most of them are just not clear. I understand that the Teaching and Learning Commons no longer is taking walk in appointments. How many times have you visited them for help? Do you have a friend or relative who could help you?

If you want my help in editing, please copy this into a word document, convert to a large font with double space, and I will edit it line by line during your final.

You have until midnight M Dec 17th to get this into shape.

Your citations have numerous problems which I can show you in the edits. You still have FN 9-12 as identical source.

All book titles should be in italics. You do this sometimes.

You need an editing buddy to get this into shape. It shouldn't take more than a few hours.

So far you have 15 points and are lacking the final version 15.

DH--DHertzGSR (talk) 03:39, 14 December 2018 (UTC)

points awarded wiki article
Dear Ms Savo

You have worked really hard and I appreciate all the changes you have made. This is not ready to publish, because too many sentences are just not clear, and the tone is not the sort of concise precision we need in a wiki article. I am awarding you 25 of the 30 points. DH--DHertzGSR (talk) 19:20, 18 December 2018 (UTC)