User talk:SatyrBot/Archive 10

If you have questions regarding a banner for this project that was placed on an article, you may leave a comment here or on the project talk page.
 * WikiProject Judaism


 * 1. I assume from that request that the template to use is WikiProject Judaism

correct


 * 2. Are there any sub/super projects related to this one, and if so, are there any banners that, if present, would mean *not* adding yours?

no
 * Actually, there are WikiProject Kabbalah, WikiProject Jewish history, WikiProject Jewish culture. The banner should not be added, but probably should not be removed if present. --Eliyak T · C 20:30, 28 August 2007 (UTC)
 * Sounds good - I won't remove them. -- SatyrTN (talk | contribs) 21:05, 28 August 2007 (UTC)
 * 3. Do you want me to automatically add a Stub, FA, or GA class, or will you want to review them yourselves?

Thanks!

yes for auto

--Java7837 22:48, 27 August 2007 (UTC)

Project Logs

 * Run #1
 * Run #2
 * Run #3
 * Run #4
 * Run #5

Bot in categories
I am not clear why the bot (or you) is placing itself into categories which are meant for articles, not users or Wikiprojects. What is the reason for it? --Blainster 10:23, 1 September 2007 (UTC)
 * Thanks for the reply. The listing looked out of place, but I guess if is only there temporarily, and is serving a good purpose, it's not a problem. The drawback is that the category is for relevant articles, and anyone who sees the bot there may be confused by it (like me).  Maybe if you renamed your page "temporary project", "current project (temporary)", or something similar, it would help to alert other users or editors that its presence is merely temporary and not a mis-categorization. --Blainster 06:47, 2 September 2007 (UTC)

Israeli cities
Why is the bot tagging Israeli cities, villages, songs, settlements, and rivers? --Shuki 19:07, 1 September 2007 (UTC)
 * Hi, Shuki! The bot is working on a list of categories provided to me by WikiProject Judaism. I suggest mentioning to them that at least one of the categories is incorrect - perhaps you could provide them with a couple articles that have been tagged that shouldn't?  They have said they'll be reviewing all the articles to make sure they haven't over-bannered.  Thanks for your input! And sorry for any inconvenience! -- SatyrTN (talk | contribs)  19:15, 1 September 2007 (UTC)
 * The bot seems to be guilty of overtagging. For example, since when is Hamas part of project Judaism? Israel, yes, Judaism, no. -- Avi 12:52, 2 September 2007 (UTC)
 * I see now where the idea was first brought up on the project page. It seems that the work should have been given much more analysis before being carried out after only a couple of days. --Shuki 20:13, 3 September 2007 (UTC)
 * A few days? The project started talking about having a bot work on 1 August.  They contacted me about it on the 10th.  I replied that I needed a category list.  On the 27th they contacted me with that list.  At the time, not being a part of the project, I assumed they had hashed out the category list. Forgive me if I assumed good faith. -- SatyrTN (talk | contribs)  22:28, 3 September 2007 (UTC)
 * Um, please don't get offended, this is a project, but then again we are all individual editors. I don't speak for the project, just my views. I must of missed the first post about this I see now way back on Aug2. I admit that I did not see most of the talk here and did not understand the pervasiveness of the job planned. --Shuki 20:27, 4 September 2007 (UTC)


 * Sorry, Shuki! Didn't mean to bite.  I've gotten a little flack for what I thought would be an easy project for the bot to do, so I'm a bit testy.  I apologize... :) -- SatyrTN (talk | contribs)  00:30, 5 September 2007 (UTC)

tagging
I noticed you are adding all the original categories are you going to add all the original categories and then remove from wikiproject the categories i speicified--Java7837 18:55, 3 September 2007 (UTC)

(I'm new to commenting on Wikipedia, please pardon me if I made a mistake):

Your Bot mistakenly added Martin Van Creveld to the WikiJudaism project. There is nothing in his Wikipedia entry (nor, I believe, in his publications) that relates to the Jewish religion, the topic of the WikiJudaism project.

Eph —Preceding unsigned comment added by Ephu437 (talk • contribs) 21:46, 4 September 2007 (UTC)

WikiProject Judaism
add all the articles of Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Judaism/Categories to WikiProject Judaism the templated used by WikiProject Judaism is Template:WikiProject Judaism --Java7837 03:51, 27 August 2007 (UTC)

Bot
I was saying you were using http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Judaism/Categories&oldid=154254756 for the categories for the bot to do and that once you finish doing that you plan on removing or transfering the cats i specified on WP:JEW Java7837 (talk • contribs) 00:15, 4 September 2007 (UTC)

WP:JEW
We have a good list Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Judaism/Categories i removed all irrelevant categories.

I have made a list of categories some of which have not been done by the bot that should not be part of wikiproject judaism also they shouldn't

move to WikiProject Israel
Category:Six-Day War Category:Kibbutz Dati Category:Roman sites in Israel Category:Ancient Greek sites in Israel Category:Cities in Judea Category:Cities in Samaria Category:Ancient Israel and Judah Category:Battles involving the Canaanites Category:Judea and Samaria Area Category:Battles of the Maccabean revolt Category:Hasmoneans Category:Roman governors of Judaea

move to WikiProject Jewish culture
Category:Yiddish Category:Yiddish-language film directors Category:Yiddish-language occupations Category:Yiddish-language poets Category:Yiddish-language writers Category:Yiddish literature Category:Yiddish periodicals Category:Yiddish singers Category:Yiddish songs Category:Yiddish theatre Category:Yiddish theatre performers Category:Yiddish words and phrases <- this one i want to do manually Category:Jewish comedy Category:Jewish culture Category:Jewish magazines Category:Jewish media Category:Jewish media in Canada Category:Jewish medical organizations Category:Jewish music Category:Judeo-Arabic languages Category:Jewish film and theatre Category:Jewish radio Category:Jewish newspapers Category:Judeo-Persian languages Category:Judeo-Romance languages Category:Jewish sports organizations Category:Ladino language Category:Linguists of Yiddish Category:Hasidic entertainers Category:Jewish clubs and societies

move to WikiProject Bible
Category:Torah cities Category:Torah events Category:Torah monarchs Category:Torah people Category:Torah places Category:Essene texts Category:Dead Sea scrolls Category:Book of Enoch Category:Book of Daniel Category:Battles involving the Canaanites Category:Biblical women in ancient warfare Category:Deuterocanonical books Category:Geography of Hebrew Bible places Category:Hebrew Bible chapters Category:Hebrew Bible cities Category:Hebrew Bible cities and countries Category:Hebrew Bible countries Category:Hebrew Bible events Category:Hebrew Bible geography Category:Hebrew Bible manuscripts Category:Hebrew Bible mountains Category:Hebrew Bible nations Category:Hebrew Bible people Category:Hebrew Bible places Category:Hebrew Bible quotations Category:Hebrew Bible rivers Category:Hebrew Bible topics Category:Hebrew Bible valleys Category:Hebrew Bible verses Category:Samaritan culture and history Category:Samaritan texts Category:Judges of ancient Israel Category:Kings of ancient Israel Category:Kings of ancient Judah Category:Kings of Edom Category:Tanakh stubs Category:Testament of Solomon Category:Non-rabbinic Jewish texts Category:Old Testament Apocrypha Category:Old Testament Apocrypha people Category:Old Testament Apocrypha places

move to WikiProject Jewish history
Category:Victims of the Inquisition Category:Works of Josephus Category:Herodian dynasty Category:Images of the Holocaust Category:Jewish Argentine history Category:Jewish Austrian history Category:Jewish Autonomous Oblast Category:Jewish Babylonian history Category:Jewish Dutch history Category:Ancient Jewish Egyptian history Category:Ancient Jewish Greek history Category:Ancient Jewish Persian history Category:Ancient Jewish Roman history  Category:Dreyfus affair Category:Jewish English history Category:Holocaust museums Category:Jewish Messiah claimants Category:Jewish museums  Category:Blood libel Category:Rothschild family Category:Jewish philanthropists Category:Jewish Ukrainian history Category:Jewish United States Supreme Court justices Category:Jewish Polish history Category:Jewish Portuguese history Category:Jewish Romanian history Category:Jewish-Roman wars Category:Jewish royalty Category:Jewish Russian and Soviet history Category:Jewish resistance during the Holocaust Category:Jewish South African history Category:Jewish Spanish history Category:Nazi anti-Semitic propaganda films Category:American Jews Category:Argentine Jewish organizations  Category:Pogrom victims

completely remove
Category:Antisemitic canards Category:Antisemitic forgeries Category:Antisemitic publications Category:Antisemitism Category:Anti-Judaism Category:Anti-Zionism

Reply from SatyrTN
Hi, Java! Here are the cats that the bot has already done, but you've removed from the current list:


 * Category:Ancient Greek sites in Israel
 * Category:Ancient Israel and Judah
 * Category:Ancient Jewish Egyptian history
 * Category:Ancient Jewish Greek history
 * Category:Ancient Jewish Persian history
 * Category:Ancient Jewish Roman history
 * Category:Anti-Judaism
 * Category:Anti-Zionism
 * Category:Antisemitic canards
 * Category:Antisemitic forgeries
 * Category:Antisemitic publications
 * Category:Antisemitism
 * Category:Archangels
 * Category:Argentine Jewish organizations
 * Category:Battles involving the Canaanites
 * Category:Battles of the Maccabean revolt
 * Category:Biblical women in ancient warfare
 * Category:Blood libel
 * Category:Book of Daniel
 * Category:Book of Enoch
 * Category:Cardozo School of Law professors
 * Category:Cities in Judea
 * Category:Cities in Samaria
 * Category:Classes of angel
 * Category:Dead Sea scrolls
 * Category:Deuterocanonical books
 * Category:Dreyfus affair
 * Category:Essene texts
 * Category:Fictional rabbis
 * Category:Geography of Hebrew Bible places
 * Category:Hasidic entertainers
 * Category:Hasmoneans
 * Category:Hebrew Bible chapters
 * Category:Hebrew Bible cities and countries
 * Category:Hebrew Bible cities
 * Category:Hebrew Bible countries
 * Category:Hebrew Bible events
 * Category:Hebrew Bible geography
 * Category:Hebrew Bible manuscripts
 * Category:Hebrew Bible mountains
 * Category:Hebrew Bible nations
 * Category:Hebrew Bible people
 * Category:Hebrew Bible places
 * Category:Hebrew Bible quotations
 * Category:Hebrew Bible rivers
 * Category:Hebrew Bible topics
 * Category:Hebrew Bible valleys
 * Category:Hebrew Bible verses
 * Category:Herodian dynasty
 * Category:Holocaust museums
 * Category:Hong Kong Jews
 * Category:Icelandic Jews
 * Category:Images of the Holocaust
 * Category:Jewish Argentine history
 * Category:Jewish Austrian history
 * Category:Jewish Autonomous Oblast
 * Category:Jewish Babylonian history
 * Category:Jewish clubs and societies
 * Category:Jewish comedy
 * Category:Jewish culture
 * Category:Jewish Dutch history
 * Category:Jewish English history
 * Category:Jewish film and theatre
 * Category:Jewish magazines
 * Category:Jewish media in Canada
 * Category:Jewish media
 * Category:Jewish medical organizations
 * Category:Jewish Messiah claimants
 * Category:Jewish museums
 * Category:Jewish music
 * Category:Jewish newspapers
 * Category:Jewish philanthropists
 * Category:Jewish Polish history

Does that look right? Should I have the bot remove the banner from those cats? -- SatyrTN (talk | contribs) 19:29, 4 September 2007 (UTC)

Only remove it from the categories i specified above not from all categories the bot has done already--69.153.67.219 21:13, 4 September 2007 (UTC)


 * Hi, Java! I probably wasn't clear about something.  SatyrBot won't be moving articles from one WikiProject to another.  It's working on WP:Judaism, so it can either add the WP:Judaism banner or it can remove the banner.  It doesn't have enough sense to move from one project to another.


 * So let me know if you would like me to remove the WP:Judaism banner from the categories you indicated or from all categories that aren't in your project? -- SatyrTN (talk | contribs) 00:45, 5 September 2007 (UTC)

mistake on Paamayim Nekudotayim
The bot added Paamayim Nekudotayim to WikiProject Judaism. This is incorrect because the article is computer science- and not Judaism-related, despite the Hebrew title. An understandable error but incorrect nonetheless. Just thought I'd mention is. --Makaristos 20:06, 31 August 2007 (UTC)

yet another error: Taj El-Din Hilaly
This man is an Australian muslim cleric. He is already in 3 far more suitable wiki-projects: Biography, Australia, and Muslim Leaders. The bot added the Jewish project right at the top, not in the box for wikiprojects. In my opinion humans are much better placed to make this kind of choice. Please stop this bot and make it much more cautious. 99of9 (talk) 01:44, 23 November 2007 (UTC)