User talk:ScottishFinnishRadish/Archive 34

Topic ban
Hi I wish for you to reconsider your decision.Monopoly31121993(2) (talk) 17:09, 29 June 2024 (UTC)

A major issue with the page Ezhava and a very recently formed page Tiyyar
hi @ScottishFinnishRadish,

I have seen that you have edited the page Ezhava and related issues with that. from the records it is clear that the ediotrs coniders ezhavas and thiyyas as synonymous and both are redirected to each other. however after violating this a new page has been created few days back, the page contradicts almost any thing the main page says and went to claim that thiyyas are a separate ethnicity. However the main page says that it is the same. Quoting from the main page Ezhava --> They are also known as Ilhava, Irava, Izhava and Erava in the south of the region; as Chovas, Chokons and Chogons in Central Travancore; and as Thiyyar, Tiyyas and Theeyas in the Malabar region. This is from the section variations from the main page ezhava. The problem is since these both are included together it would require to split like the entire pages, if it is separate. I have checked the past edits and archieves and the main admins had made it clear that both are same. It would require splitting up the page "Ezhava" too. Else it is like creating 10. 20 pages with the same name. Also thiyyas are being counted as a separate ethnicity in the page tiyyar in most of the cases including the govt records the name is thiyya, so like it is extra confusion. All the details are well discussed in the main page ezhava. the current page tiyyar even discusses, genetics like indo aryans etc, is a mere news article enough enough for this claims ?? the article claims things like separate dialect for thiyya. I mean how can this be in an ecyclopedia even a news article wont say this?? Can u please check into this ? I think if it is separate the entire page need to be splitted up ? What do u think ? Lisa121996 (talk) 04:30, 1 July 2024 (UTC)


 * Also this was redirected to ezhava earlier by other admins, now somebody opened the issue again it seeems . Can u please look into this Lisa121996 (talk) 04:34, 1 July 2024 (UTC)

New message from Red-tailed hawk
— Red-tailed hawk  (nest) 03:36, 2 July 2024 (UTC)

IP editors
I'd like to ask you about how best to handle this situation. They have been targeting this RfC, and South China Sea articles which also involve registered accounts KingKeyBoy and Ed8694. One IP group is from the Philippines: 103.152.9.17   Second group from the Netherlands:   Third group from Japan:    Fourth from Indonesia:. Most of them became active in June and are single purpose. Would SPI or page protection be helpful in any way? Vacosea (talk) 20:46, 3 July 2024 (UTC)