User talk:Shirshorn/sandbox

Hey Sarah, sorry I accidentally originally put this on your sandbox edits. However I thought your right draft was excellent and you did a great job of giving information about censorship without showing bias. I also like the idea of having a few specific examples of major books that are well known to be controversial and your draft of the Catcher in the Rye example was comprehensive and well written. I saw some of the other books you were thinking of adding and I think they're great and you should go ahead with them. I left more comments on the doc about a few stylistic and grammatical things but overall the draft was excellent and should be implemented into the finished article. Chrismulterer (talk) 16:05, 28 November 2016 (UTC)

Hi Sarah, it's Isaac. I read through your writing from your sandbox. The draft does an excellent job of remaining neutral, and giving detailed explanations of definitions and different cases included. I have very few suggestions. I shared a google doc where I highlighted minor edits on grammar. It seems that you have hyperlinked a lot of pages that have additional info, which is the only other suggestion I would have had. The definitions in your article may be helpful in trying to define the ethnic studies cases on my page.Isaacschley (talk) 18:00, 28 November 2016 (UTC)