User talk:SilkTork/Conflicts


 * 1) Pypex 03:15, 18 January 2006 (UTC) Objection: changing references to "Real ale" into "cask ale" it quite arbitrary as it very much depends on who's definition you're using.

Response: Real Ale is a term used by CAMRA and refers to beer still on the yeast and not served under pressure and using traditional ingredients...I'll look again at the descriptions to see if they need any more work.

Conclusion: The articles Real ale and Cask ale have developed. The articles continue to grow. No further comments from Pypex, so this complaint is still open.


 * 1) Pypex 03:15, 18 January 2006 (UTC) Objection: your treatment of the brakspear article defies logic, so I reverted it.

Response: '''There are two Brakspear entries. One is for the old brewery company which sold off the brewery building and the beer brand names, but kept the pub chain. The other is for Refresh UK who bought the rights to the brand names.'''

Development: ''Hi, just to let you know, User:SilkTork made further changes to Brakspear since you reverted his previous changes. --Daniel11 20:52, 18 January 2006 (UTC)'' I dont really agree with the page splitting as its not "the done thing" but he seems to know far more than I do when it comes to breweries so im not going to contest, it can allways be re-merged when the pages are more a bit more static.--Pypex 16:59, 19 January 2006 (UTC)

Conclusion: The articles Brakspear and Brakspear (Refresh UK) still exist with moderate ongoing editing. No further comments from Pypex, so this complaint is still open.


 * 1) Mais oui! 14:08, 18 January 2006 (UTC) Objection: Please stop deleting categories from all the beer articles.

Response: I took away links mixing closed down breweries with active breweries. (I created a new cat: Closed British Breweries)

Development: ''Why are you continuing to add supercategories? Mais oui! 19:09, 19 January 2006 (UTC) 'I don't understand the exact and precise nature of my activity that is causing you a problem. SilkTork 19:33, 19 January 2006 (UTC)' If we put all articles in supercats too then the parent cat just gets totally clogged up. That is why we have subcategories: to make cats easier to navigate, and to cross reference.... I apologise. Mais oui! 20:39, 19 January 2006 (UTC)'' (Mais oui! was concerned to keep breweries divided into Scotland, England, Wales, etc, rather than under United Kingdom or British Isles)

Conclusion: Category:Closed British Breweries still exists with moderate ongoing editing. British Isles breweries are divided as Mais oui! wishes into regional areas. The nationalistic implications of this situation is an ongoing debate throughout Wikipedia.


 * 1) Mais oui! 18:55, 19 January 2006 (UTC) Objection: Now you have started blanking pages! ... Please stop your actions immediately.

Response: '''Young's ... was a duplicate of Young's Brewery... I cleared the Young's page and re-directed people to the Young's Brewery page.'''

Conclusion: Young's Brewery article still exists with a redirect from Young's. Editing is ongoing.