User talk:Simulacra11

Hello,

Regarding your comment that The Jerusalem Talmud was also know as "Palestinian Talmud", I have to tell you that I don't know on which authority you are relying, but it is worng!

First of all, the name of this Talmud is with connection to the place of goverment or base of Israel, Jerusalem although it might not have been written specifically in Jerasalem, as the Bavli Talmud is refering to the place of where the Jews were exiled to and wrote it there.

Saying Plastenian Talmud is like saying it was written by Palestenains because it relates to the people and not the place, but it cannot also be called the Palestina Talmud, because Israel was known back then as Israel or the Holy land so factualy it is impossible that the Jewish people will call it like this or for anyobdy else to call it like this.

There might be a non Jewish fraud of a scholar motivated by political views who wants to call it like this, but it is completely wrong historically, factual and religiously!furthermore, it is even offensive! Especially when you say "it was also known as"- although no Jewish person will ever know it as a Palestinian, and it was never know as such!

You could say that the Quran is also known as the book of Israel, but it is not known as such! even if some idiotic "scholar" will say it is known as such! Simulacra11 (talk) 19:30, 17 July 2008 (UTC)