User talk:Siraltroetro

test

Welcome
Hello Siraltroetro, and welcome to Wikipedia. Concerning your removal of the bit about Iiboshi, and your additions of new sections at Battles Without Honor and Humanity, please read Reliable sources, No original research and Verifiability. I do not doubt your additions and your assertions about Iiboshi, but since they are not cited to a source I have have removed them. If the Japanese Wiki article cites the sources on which its information is based, please cite those sources-- not the Wikipedia article-- in your translation. Wikipedia itself is not considered a "reliable source" since anyone can edit it. If you are a native Japanese speaker, you can make valuable contributions by citing Japanese sources. But as Wikipedia editors, we cannot simply write things that we "know" to be true, no matter our expertise in real life. That would make us original authors, and we are not expert authors here writing our own books. We are only editors who must cite our contributions to "reliable sources". Even if the currently cited source about Iiboshi is incorrect, it is still a "reliable source" about this subject which should be cited at the article. If it is incorrect, please provide a source which refutes the claims. That way, at least, an English reader who comes across the incorrect assertion in the book will be able to see that this information is mistaken, not because a Wikipedia editor says so, but because a "reliable source" says so. Regards. Dekkappai (talk) 16:15, 16 May 2009 (UTC)
 * P.S. I watched all the interviews with Japanese filmmakers and writers on the Extra disk of the "Battles" DVD box this morning hoping to find some information about Iiboshi. I saw several mentions of Kasahara Kazuo, the screenwriter, but nothing about Iiboshi. I hope you can provide a good source on the information, and hope you stay to contribute more at Wikipedia. Regards. Dekkappai (talk) 16:30, 16 May 2009 (UTC)
 * Hello, Siraltroetro. "We Japanese" is a piss-poor excuse for unsourced editing. If I edited English-language articles claiming "We Americans", "We English-speakers" "know" things, I'd rightly be laughed off Wikipedia. I hope you see the foolishness of this position and provide sources for your edits. As for the "wrong" version, please show me the sources that show it is wrong and I will happily revert it. I will not revert it on your say-so however. No, I am not Chris Desjardins, and if you read correctly, you would understand that I believe his source is wrong and that you are right. Your article on Koichi Iiboshi is unsourced and POV, and should be tagged as such. I will not do so because prefer to make constructive edits. I hope you learn to as well. Dekkappai (talk) 23:11, 16 May 2009 (UTC)

Asahi
In an article you just created, you created a link to Asahi. However, this is a disambiguation page and it is not clear to the reader which Asahi you meant. If possible please fix this with a direct link to the proper page. Soap Talk/Contributions 22:12, 16 May 2009 (UTC)

Fixed.--Siraltroetro (talk) 22:43, 16 May 2009 (UTC)